Pure Appl. Chem., 2003, Vol. 75, No. 11-12, pp. 2575-2591
http://dx.doi.org/10.1351/pac200375112575
Risk perception: A chemical industry view of endocrine disruption in wildlife
Abstract:
Manufactured chemicals are essential to the vast array
of goods and services that contribute to modern life. Their benefits
are innumerable, and society is entirely dependent upon them. At the
same time, there is an increasing awareness of the concept of environmental
impacts. The challenge is to achieve the appropriate balance between
the benefits and risks from chemicals, so that we all may enjoy the
benefits of chemicals without significant detriment to current and future
human and wildlife health. Ecological risk assessment is the mechanism
that allows potential environmental chemical exposure to be benchmarked
against hazardous properties so that risk is acceptable and environmental
health is not impaired. Chemical management decisions based on such
assessments are said to be risk-based. Within the context of environmental
risk assessment practice for endocrine disruption, industry would support
a position that:
- endorsed the risk assessment process;
- recognized that endocrine disruption is not an adverse effect per se, but rather a potential mechanism of action;
- gave precedent to population-level effects instead of individual-level effects;
- employed a tiered approach to hazard assessment; emphasized standardized and validated effects testing methodologies;
- recognized that exposure per se does not necessarily constitute a risk;
- considered relative potency (i.e., evaluation of the dose levels and mechanisms producing toxic adverse effects and determining whether the critical effect arises via an endocrine mechanism or another mechanism);
- benchmarked risk against loss of benefits; and
- evaluated risk within the context of overall risk from both natural and anthropogenic substances with common modes of action.
To help address uncertainty surrounding the risk from Endocrine Active
Substances (EAS) to wildlife, the chemical industry -- via the Long-Range
Research Initiative (LRI) -- has implemented a research program aimed
at identifying and addressing knowledge gaps and establishing internationally
harmonized testing methodologies in cooperation with other stakeholders.
Details of individual projects within the current LRI research program
are presented.